In an industry that often tells creators to simply “figure out their brand,” First Pitch founders Athena Partington and Gabrielle Babson are rewriting the playbook one connection at a time.
Breaking into the influencer industry can feel like navigating unfamiliar territory. Between building an audience, securing brand partnerships, establishing a personal identity, and learning how to monetize creative work, the path to becoming a successful creator is rarely straightforward. For creators of color, particularly Black women, these challenges can be even more complicated by an industry that doesn’t always recognize or invest in our talent.
And while the advice circulating online often sounds the same; “figure out your brand” both founders believe there’s more to building a sustainable creative career than finding the perfect niche or curating an online presence.
Founded in 2025 by friends and business partners Athena Partington and Gabrielle (Gabby) Babson, First Pitch is a talent development agency committed to equipping creators of color with the resources, mentorship, and knowledge needed to navigate the influencer and creator economy with confidence. Rather than offering comprehensive solutions, the agency prioritizes understanding each creator’s individual goals, identifying opportunities that align with their purpose, and helping them recognize their value.
For Athena and Gabby, the idea was rooted in a shared understanding of the industry and a desire to make it more accessible for the creatives coming behind them.

A Shared Vision, A New Beginning
Although their professional journeys took different directions, both founders brought valuable perspectives to the table.
Athena, a New Jersey-based mother of two, has worked on both sides of influencer marketing since 2019, gaining firsthand insight into the relationships between brands, talent, and the evolving creator landscape. Gabby, a creative who once considered pursuing several different career paths, including nursing, eventually earned a degree in public relations and began building her career in talent management.
After reconnecting years after attending high school together, the two recognized an opportunity to combine their respective experiences and turn their conversations about the industry into something tangible.
Their shared vision was simple: create a space that was closely aligned with Black creatives and offer the type of guidance they felt was missing from the industry.
As Gabby explained, much of their motivation came from recognizing that emerging creators were entering an increasingly competitive space without necessarily understanding how to navigate it.
“A lot of the people who were just entering this field really didn’t know how to approach it,” she shared.
That realization sparked a bigger conversation between the two founders. How could they make creative education more accessible? How could they help creators understand their worth, negotiate fair compensation, and confidently represent themselves in an industry that continues to evolve?
“What can we do to kind of elevate creative education and get people more inspired to learn more about, you know, how to make sure that they’re getting paid what they deserve and how to represent themselves?” Gabby recalled.
Those questions ultimately became the foundation for First Pitch.
Beyond the Brand: Understanding Your Positioning
In a digital landscape where everyone seems to be building a personal brand, it can be easy for creators to feel pressured to follow the same formula. However, First Pitch challenges that expectation by encouraging creators to look beyond aesthetics, follower counts, and trending content to understand what they actually bring to the table.
For Gabby, one of the biggest challenges she continues to see among creators is positioning.
“Positioning is the biggest challenge that I’ve continued to see [with creators],” she explained. “They don’t necessarily have the language, or they don’t necessarily know how to position themselves in the way that gets them seen in the right spaces.”
Through its mentorship, First Pitch works with creators to identify their strengths, clarify their professional identities, and pursue opportunities that genuinely align with their goals and the impact they want to make. That sometimes means offering advice that goes against conventional industry wisdom.
According to Athena, establishing a personal brand isn’t necessarily the first step for everyone. Before determining how to market themselves, she shares that “you have to understand what kind of creator or influencer you are in this space” and how their individual talents can translate into meaningful opportunities.
Athena often points to journalist and tastemaker Blake Newby as an example of someone who has built a distinct presence by leaning into her mission, perspective, and unique skill set.
The takeaway? There isn’t one formula for success. Understanding your value and learning how to communicate it can be far more impactful than trying to fit into an existing mold.
Building a Business Without Losing the Joy
Entrepreneurship often comes with the expectation that success requires constant productivity, perfectly structured schedules, and an evenly distributed work-life balance. But for Athena and Gabby, building First Pitch has meant learning to embrace a more fluid approach.
Athena shares she isn’t particularly interested in the idea of balance, especially in an industry that is constantly shifting. Instead, she describes the company’s approach as being “fueled by vibes.”
“I like to make jokes about it, and I like to keep it lighthearted because—especially in this industry and especially when you are advocating for creatives of color—it can feel very daunting and very frustrating,” she shared. “So a big thing for me in First Pitch is it’s this space where…the work is really fueled by vibes.”
That philosophy isn’t about taking the work any less seriously. It’s about recognizing when to lean in, when to pull back, and where their energy is best spent.
There are seasons when the founders are fully immersed in programming, working closely with multiple mentees, and bringing larger initiatives to life. One example was their Black History Month dinner in early 2026, hosted in collaboration with Dove and Lyft.

Other seasons look a little different, with the pair working behind the scenes to refine their mentorship curriculum, strengthen internal systems, and thoughtfully develop the agency’s next steps. And sometimes, moving the business forward means stepping away from it altogether.
For Athena and Gabby, preserving their friendship outside of their professional partnership is just as important as building the company. Whether it’s catching a weekend movie or simply making time to spend together, those moments allow them to reconnect beyond the responsibilities of entrepreneurship.
It’s a reminder that building something meaningful shouldn’t require losing the relationships and experiences that make the journey worthwhile.
Redefining Success Through Community
For both founders, one of the most important lessons they’ve carried into their work is that professional goals should reflect the season of life you’re currently in.
Success doesn’t look the same for everyone, and the opportunities a creator pursues should make sense for their individual circumstances, priorities, and aspirations.
“I think depending on the stage of life that you’re in, you know, the expectations and the goals that you set can look very different. So when it comes to advice [on entrepreneurship], it’s really hard to provide because we don’t all live the same lives,” Gabby explained.
That understanding is central to how First Pitch approaches mentorship. Rather than positioning themselves as people with all the answers, Athena and Gabby prioritize listening, asking questions, and understanding the individuals they work with.

Their approach recognizes that creators aren’t simply portfolios, platforms, or potential brand partnerships. They’re people with different experiences, responsibilities, ambitions, and definitions of fulfillment.
And that perspective extends beyond the mentorship program itself.
Since launching, First Pitch has continued to build recognition within the creative community, including winning The People’s Pitch competition in collaboration with GROWN Magazine. But for the founders, the relationships they’ve cultivated and the community they’ve created are among their most meaningful accomplishments.
As Gabby shared, connecting with creators and women who share their experiences and aspirations is what makes the work especially rewarding. That sense of connection also motivates the founders to continue improving their systems, strengthening their resources, and showing up for the people who trust them with their creative journeys.
What’s Next For First Pitch?
As the creator economy continues to evolve, First Pitch is focused on growing its community while remaining intentional about how it expands.
For Athena and Gabby, the future isn’t necessarily about taking on the largest number of projects or pursuing every opportunity that comes their way. Instead, it’s about maximizing the impact of the work they choose to do and building an agency that feels both accessible and personal.

Their approach is a refreshing reminder that growth doesn’t always have to be measured by quantity. Sometimes, the most meaningful progress comes from investing deeply in a smaller community, creating opportunities for genuine connection, and making sure the people involved feel seen and supported.
In an industry where authenticity is increasingly valued but meaningful representation and access remain ongoing challenges, First Pitch is working to create something beyond another talent development agency. It’s building a community where creators of color can learn, advocate for themselves, recognize their worth, and develop careers on their own terms.
Because sometimes, getting your first pitch isn’t about having everything figured out. It’s about having the right people in your corner to help you recognize what’s possible and the confidence to make your next move.
